Raise Awareness of Affordable Housing
As part of their Housing for All Campaign, the Canadian Housing and Renewal Association is holding a series of roundtables regarding housing policy. These roundtables will include key local housing and homelessness stakeholders, as well as candidates from all federal political parties. One such event has already taken place in Winnipeg and future events will be held across Canada throughout the summer.
If you are interested in attending and/or helping to organize and promote a roundtable in your municipality, please email Catherine Fortin LeFaivre.
Microsoft Cloud Touches Down in Canada
On Tuesday, June 2, 2015, WW COO for Microsoft, Kevin Turner and Microsoft Canada President, Janet Kennedy announced the establishment of Canada’s very own Microsoft Datacentres, part of Microsoft’s commitment to bringing opportunity and innovation to Canada. Microsoft plans to deliver commercial cloud services - Azure, Office 365 and Dynamics CRM Online – from Toronto and Quebec City in 2016, to help further empower Canadian businesses be globally competitive.
Microsoft is a leading provider of hyper-scale cloud services, offering over 200 cloud-based services to 1 billion customers and 20 million businesses worldwide. Over the years, Microsoft has heard from Ontario businesses and public sector organizations about the benefits of data residency, lower latency and geo redundancy with the availability of local infrastructure. When completed, these new locally deployed services will address data residency and compliance considerations for Microsoft customers and partners of all shapes and sizes who are embracing cloud computing.
Microsoft’s locally-available cloud services will offer a new level of cloud-based solutions to private business, public sector and government organizations. The services offered via the local datacentres will also create new opportunities for Microsoft Canada’s 12,000+ partner ecosystem, comprised of hosters, independent software vendors (ISVs), system integrators and others creating real impact for Ontario’s economy.
Interested in learning more – view highlights from the Microsoft Datacenters announcement here and about Microsoft’s cloud offerings here.
PSD WEBINAR: Accelerating Brownfield Renewal in your Community
During this PSD Webinar you will hear from experts from two Canadian municipalities - City of Kingston and the City of Edmonton - that have implemented successful brownfield renewal programs in their respective communities. Stéphanie Bohdanow from the Federation of Canadian Municipalities will introduce FCM's new program "Leadership in Brownfield Renewal" (LiBRe) and how it can benefit your community.
When? August 20th 1:00 PM – 2:00 PM EDT
CAMA members receive 25% off using discount code: CAMA
REGISTER HERE: https://publicsectordigest.com/products/view/784
CAMA Awards of Excellence Presented by Ravenhill Group Inc.
Ravenhill Group Inc. proudly presented the CAMA Awards of Excellence at the 44th Annual Conference held in Jasper, Alberta. Ravenhill Group is Canada’s municipal search specialists, meeting the growing demand for excellent Chief Administrative Officers and other municipal leaders through ethical head-hunting™. Ravenhill does this by bringing the very best men and women face to face with the opportunity in a municipality … an opportunity that they were unaware of because - simply put - they weren't thinking of a job change. Please visit: www.ravenhillgroup.com for more information.
2015 CAMA Willis Award for Innovation -City of Westmount, QC (Population between 20,001 and 100,000)
Jake Rudolph, Chair of the CAMA Awards/CAMA Board Representative for British Columbia and Yukon;
Bruce Malcolm, President of Ravenhill Inc, Awards Partner; Councillor Cynthia Lulham, City of Westmount;
Robert Hughes, CAMA President
Westmont Recreation Centre
Congratulations to the City of Westmount on being the recipient of the CAMA Willis Award for Innovation for their Recreation Centre!
The City of Westmount recently replaced its aging municipal arena and pool with a new and unique sports facility – the largest project ever in Westmount’s 140-year history, and a project incorporating, in essence, the world’s first underground ice rinks.
Completed in 2014, the 8,270 m² (89,000 ft²) Westmount Recreation Centre (WRC) is located at the edge of historic Westmount Park, and features:
two underground NHL-sized ice rinks with a green roof,
a competition-standard outdoor pool and wading pond,
three multi-purpose activity rooms,
a teen centre,
the Pavilion in the Park: a community café,
the city’s sports & recreation administrative offices,
numerous energy-efficiency features, and
a stormwater management system.
The City used a Design-Build approach for the $40 million project, which integrated design services and construction services into a single contract, giving the City the ability to establish a time frame and cost ceiling up front.
Close monitoring throughout the 18-month long project, which began in summer 2012, was carried out by the City’s internal steering committee. The sports complex was delivered to citizens essentially on time and on budget.
The building’s innovative design, energy efficiencies and low operating costs have resulted in savings for the municipality and recognition from the construction industry and in municipal circles. The WRC obtained LEED-Gold certification in 2015.
Below you will also have the opportunity to view a story written by Peter F. Trent, the Mayor of the City of Westmount and author of The Merger Delusion, published by McGill-Queen’s University Press. Mayor Trent was an inventor and entrepreneur before being elected in 1991. He is currently serving his fifth term as Mayor.
Innovation at Work: Lessons Learned in Building the World’s First Underground Arena
Innovate. The word comes from the Latin “to renew.” People working in local government should constantly seek to renew their ways of doing things. I am not advocating change for the sake of change – for which politicians have a particular propensity – but change that leads to doing things better.
Why should innovation be the exclusive province of the private sector? Why can’t we instill the spirit of entrepreneurship in local government? Small municipalities, especially, should exploit their size by tapping into their intrinsic agility in problem-solving – just as small businesses have always done.
At both the political and administrative levels, public-sector leadership needs to welcome innovation by encouraging imagination and inventiveness. Mind you, just coming up with an innovative concept is not enough. To make an idea happen, one has to inspire others, to galvanize collectively, to light a fire in many bellies. This is not an easy task in the public sector. Many political and administrative leaders have allowed themselves to become risk-adverse, unimaginative, and intellectually unresponsive simply by force of habit.
Take committees. Committees should be incubators of ideas by challenging their members to stretch their thinking; instead they usually serve as graveyards for ideas-in-the-making. A creative committee is usually a contradiction in terms. Committees generally knock the rough edges off a concept, file it down to some predetermined form, and then proceed to smooth whatever remains until an amorphous unrecognizable blob appears. But it’s the committee’s blob and they’re proud of it.
Many municipal leaders just assume their administrations are made up of a collection of automatons resistant to doing anything other than by rote, by committee, and by the book. Well, perhaps they are; but they’ve been allowed to become that way. The safest course is the habitual, time-honoured, course. Don’t stick your head above the parapet, or you might get picked off. That’s true; but on the other hand, you just might get picked out.
Successful innovation comes from creativity; but creativity necessarily constrained by judgment. Creativity and judgment are two qualities one would think are rarely found inhabiting the same person, or even the same department. Well, one would make a grievous error in assuming them to be an alien pair, because creativity tempered by judgment makes the best combination of qualities for politicians or public administrators to possess. And you know what? These two qualities can be learned. Not taught, mind you. Learned through experience. And greying hair is not mandatory; young people can have excellent judgment. They are the quick learners who have made mistakes and then honed their judgment by being honest enough to recognize the mistakes, not shifting the blame on others.
Now on to an example of public-sector innovation in my little bailiwick, the City of Westmount. By the way, innovation is not new to us. In 1913, Westmount was the first municipality in Canada to adopt the City Manager form of government, and, three years later, to create a local architectural and planning board. Then, one hundred years later, we built the world’s first underground arena.
It happened this way. In 2008, Westmount had decided it was time to replace its creaky 50-year-old arena and its leaky municipal swimming pool. Because of new activities to be added, the whole rebuilt facility would eventually come to be called the Westmount Recreation Centre (WRC). Owing to these new activities, combined with two NHL-sized ice rinks to replace the former one-and-one-half rinks, the resultant – above-ground – WRC would have been a massive industrial shed looming some 35 feet high, 500 feet long, and 120 feet wide. As well as blocking views, this ungainly behemoth would have swallowed up great swaths of parkland. Indeed, because the proposed building would have taken up so much land, it had to have costly underground parking. In addition, while a new swimming pool could be shoehorned in next to the building, there was no space left over to fit in the existing three junior tennis courts.
In order to reduce the land taken up by the projected WRC, I thought of two stacked rinks with one underground. But that approach was impractical; for one thing, there’s the permafrost that establishes itself under an ice rink. It was also a half-measure. Then, by October 2009, just before returning as Mayor after a multi-year sabbatical, I was convinced that both rinks should be buried. This had the advantage of liberating all the parkland that had been “under” the old arena.
I had noticed that arenas generally have no windows; so it was a use that lent itself to being placed underground. Another advantage is that the temperature 30 feet down remains at 59ºF year-long, which leads to energy savings in maintaining ice, allowing one rink to operate cheaply in the summer. In the same way, before refrigeration, blocks of ice were sometimes buried to remain frozen for summer use.
I had no trouble convincing City Council and the City Manager of the merits of thinking, not just outside the box, but specifically under the box. A small cadre of citizens, however, were very skeptical – and very vocal. They bitterly fought the project to the end.
Even aside from the naysayers, making the WRC happen wasn’t a walk in the park. In order to resist the lateral forces of the earth, the structure had to have walls of reinforced concrete two-and-one-half feet thick. The steel girders supporting the green-space above had to be nearly five feet deep; and, in order to span each rink, 107 feet long. After all, supporting columns in the middle of an ice rink would tend to cramp a hockey-player’s style.
So the structural costs were very high, to which one had to add the massive costs of excavation. On the other hand, we saved a bundle on the exterior envelope, which was, after all, mostly earth. It is true that in the suburbs, one can build an arena clad in corrugated steel; however, in the City of Westmount (an enclave in downtown Montreal), that sort of material is not acceptable. So we would have had to clad an above-ground arena in noble materials such as brick and stone.
And then there’s the value of liberating an acre and a half of scarce green-space: easily worth some C$8 million in Westmount. Once this “free land” was taken into account, going underground was cheaper than building above-ground. Unfortunately, in our case, we came across more contaminated soil than was estimated, and the cost of disposal was not cheap. Still, considering the extra land liberated, the underground solution came out ahead. Including an exterior pool, tennis courts, exercise rooms, a teen centre, a pavilion-in-the-park, administrative offices, and 13 changing rooms, the total cost for the entire 90,000 ft² project was a little over C$40 million. While over twice the size of the facility it replaced, the WRC uses less energy – one of the reasons it recently earned a LEED gold certification. In fact, the heat taken out of water to make the ice is used to heat the swimming pool.
It was only after we started detailed design work of the WRC that we came to realize that it would house the world’s first underground rinks. Certainly, no other arena has a park on top!
Westmount also innovated financially. As we did for the 1995 restoration and expansion of the Westmount Public Library, we used fundraising to help pay for the building of the WRC. The C$6 million donated by citizens substantially reduced property taxes funding the WRC.
Then there was the way in which we went about building the WRC. After a false start with the traditional design-bid-build method, I persuaded Council to go to the design-build method; and, to oversee the project from concept to completion, to create a design and construction steering committee. This committee, which was comprised of architects, a project manager, City managers, and two members of City Council, met weekly. It controlled the direction of the project with an iron fist, approved design changes when necessary, and fought hard to keep the extras under control when the inevitable unforeseen events occurred.
With design-build, you describe, in the utmost detail, your building program and you let the competing contractors scratch their heads as to how they’ll meet your needs within the set budget. In fact, as a bonus, our contractor’s architects came up with the idea of exploiting the site’s slope to permit windows in those parts of the WRC that were not housing the rinks.
So the design-build technique requires innovation; in other words, creativity with judgment: a concept that brings us back to our main theme. It was creativity with judgment that made the WRC unique in the world. And proved that innovation can happen in local government.
Peter F. Trent is the Mayor of the City of Westmount and author of The Merger Delusion, published by McGill-Queen’s University Press. Mayor Trent was an inventor and entrepreneur before being elected in 1991. He is currently serving his fifth term as Mayor.
Do you have a story for our next issue?
Let us know by contacting email@example.com