News Release< Previous Article 41 of 91 Next >
Okanagan Water Board Responds to Federal Announcement on Mussels & MilfoilOkanagan Basin Water Board
KELOWNA - The Okanagan Basin Water Board is pleased to see a reprieve from the proposed federal endangered listing of the native Rocky Mountain Ridged Mussel (RMRM). The matter has been referred for further study and consultation. The Water Board is now renewing its call to be permitted to continue rototilling invasive milfoil weeds at public beaches and boating areas.
“We are very pleased with this decision. It allows more flexibility for us to manage invasive milfoil, keep the beaches clean, and protect water quality” said Anna Warwick Sears, Executive Director for the Water Board (OBWB). “Milfoil degrades the environment for all species, as well as the public’s access to the lake. Now we just need the province to renew our permit to operate in our historical treatment areas. We understand that this is within the discretion of the B.C. Minister of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development.”
At issue was a proposed listing of the RMRM1 under the federal Species at Risk Act (SARA) which would greatly increase restrictions on the Water Board (OBWB)’s milfoil control program. Last fall, in an effort to protect the mussel, the province ruled that the board was not allowed to rototill within 100 metres of any live RMRM or shell fragment.
Milfoil is an invasive weed that was introduced to our valley in the 1970s, possibly by a boater that brought it from another region, or someone dumping their aquarium contents in the lake. In the 1970s and 1980s the province experimented with various control methods and the most effective was found to be winter rototilling which removes the plant’s root system and reduces the density and extent of infested areas. A second method is harvesting, used by the OBWB in summer, which mows the plant to approximately two metres below the surface. Harvesting is mostly for esthetics since it does nothing to prevent the expansion of the infestation. Previously, the OBWB was permitted to rototill the milfoil to protect public beaches and boating areas, a small fraction of the lakeshore.
Provincial restrictions on the OBWB’s rototilling operation have become stricter over the last several years, intended to extend blanket protection for the native mussel along Okanagan lakeshores. However, a 2015 study conducted for the province found healthy populations in the Okanagan River channel, although this was not considered in the proposal to list the species. There is no evidence that RMRM survive in dense milfoil beds, and much research demonstrating that milfoil degrades habitat for native species.
In April, the board put its concerns in a letter to the provincial and federal governments, asking for further study. This was followed by letters of support from several local governments, chambers of commerce, the Thompson Okanagan Tourism Association, and others.
“Those with a connection to the Okanagan, of all political stripes and backgrounds, understand the importance of milfoil control in our lakes,” Sears added. “We appreciate the advocacy on our behalf by Liberal Stephen Fuhr, Kelowna-Lake Country MP, who took our case to the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans. We also appreciate the support we received from the Standing Committee for Fisheries and Oceans, where I received invitations to present our case in Ottawa in April by Conservative MP Mel Arnold and NDP MP Gord Johns, and where we received unanimous support for our weed control program.”
Sears added there are three items the OBWB wants to see addressed now:
- a full public consultation process on listing the RMRM, with adequate notice and time to respond, and public meetings to discuss the implications of the listing for Okanagan communities;
- An economic analysis conducted by the federal government, looking at how the SARA listing (and thus prohibitions on rototilling milfoil) will affect milfoil weed growth, impacts on water quality, beach access, tourism and the Okanagan economy, and
- A permanent exemption by the province for the OBWB’s milfoil control activities, allowing the agency to continue to work along public beach and boating areas where it has been rototilling for over 30 years, representing only a small fraction of the entire lakeshores.
Now that the RMRM is no longer under immediate consideration for an endangered listing, the OBWB hopes the provincial government will reconsider their prohibitions against milfoil rototilling.
“It’s within the government’s authority to issue the permit and allow us to resume our weed control operations,” added Sears. “This is a question of regulatory balance. It seems like every other natural resource decision in B.C. takes time to consider the needs of society and the economy, as well as native species, and this one should too. We are only asking to continue our operations in high-value public areas. The people need their beaches, and milfoil causes harm to a whole range of environmental values. It needs to be controlled.”
1 RMRM mussels are much larger than the invasive zebra and quagga mussels the OBWB has been raising the alarm about. The RMRM can grow to 12.5 cm (almost 5 inches) long and has a prominent ridge that runs along the top of the shell. By comparison, zebra and quagga mussels are about the size of your thumbnail (1.5 to 2 cm, or just under 1 inch) and are striped.
Corinne Jackson, OBWB – Communications Director